Here the damage award is further supported by the remaining tortious interference claim. Galdieri-Ambrosini, 136 F.3d at 287. A number of these now former employees testified (at the preliminary injunction hearing) that because Conseco was leaving the subprime lending market, they worried about their future, especially considering the fact that they worked on commission. 2001). Copyright 2001-document.write(new Date().getFullYear()) Fair Isaac Corporation. We are satisfied that North American's conduct was sufficiently reprehensible to support the jury's award of punitive damages. Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided. We, however, affirmed the decision of the district court to deny the injunction. P. 50(b); Martin H. Redish, 9 Moore's Federal Practice 50.41 (3d ed.2003). For Bolt, it's thousands of day-to-day employees with mortgages, children in college, and tight budgets who . Rule 50(a) requires that challenges to the sufficiency of the evidence must be raised initially at the close of the evidence. The company said it would divest of non-core assets, and it sold seven percent of its stock to private investment firm Thomas H. Lee Company for $478 million. North American argues that the award is based solely on its net worth and is so excessive that it violates due process. You sign a promissory note that you'll pay it back per the agreed schedule, and the lender secures the loan with a Deed of Trust that's filed at the courthouse. GE Consumer Finance, a unit of General Electric Co., will buy the assets of Mill Creek Bank, a wholly owned subsidiary of Conseco Finance, for $310 million. Meridian Enters. On appeal, North American offers an eloquent and persuasive argument regarding the stringent requirements relating to the calculation of lost profits, particularly in relation to "net" profits. The bank should mail you a check for the remaining balance in your account. Conseco Fin. CFN would pay $700 million for most of the operations of Conseco Finance, which employs 5,400 people. It determined that Conseco's lead sheets and documents in its loan files are trade secrets, but also determined that Conseco's customer lists and certain financial information are not trade secrets. In 1998 Conseco diversified and moved into finance and lending by acquiring Green Tree Financial Corporation, the nation's leading lender of mobile home loans. Who bought GE Consumer Finance? In addition, Hilbert sought firms that had developed unique insurance and annuity products or had devised innovative distribution systems for their offerings. One of the most important aspects of this world is the emergence of man as a creator. Author: Mariposa, California. Conseco's troubles began two years ago, in what some say was a foreshadowing of Enron and other celebrated collapses. The district court, however, denied Conseco's remaining request for injunctive relief relating to North American's solicitation of its employees. These documents contained information concerning Conseco's internal operations, including monthly retail point income reports generated by each Conseco office, reports ranking the retail volume by branch, reports of retail loans funded by region, financial summaries of each branch, expense ratio reports, expense analysis reports, expense analysis retail volume variance reports, and reports on credit insurance protection. It purchased Lincoln Income Life Insurance Co. and Bankers National Life Insurance Co. for $32 million and $118 million, respectively. However, North American neither returned the stolen information nor discouraged its employees' use of Conseco's loan files and lead sheets. Conseco endured a string of disparaging articles in major business journals in the early 1990s that questioned its integrity. Walsh, 332 F.3d at 1159; LeSueur Creamery, Inc. v. Haskon, Inc., 660 F.2d 342, 346 n. 7 (8th Cir. Bristol also returned a number of documents at his deposition, in accordance with the district court's TRO. The facts and issues in this case arise from actions taken by North American to acquire information about individuals that is contained in Conseco's confidential files. Chief Judge Loken did not participate in the consideration or decision of this case, Formerly known as Green Tree Financial Servicing Corporation, Conseco also employs other strategies to generate new business including internet advertising, telemarketing campaigns, "cross-marketing" of current customers, direct mail, television, radio, and yellow page advertising, and referrals from various business associates, One of North American's own witnesses admitted that North American had improperly taken Conseco's documents and repeatedly lied about it during the discovery process, His estimate was based on an average loan size in the Midwest of $85,000, The unfair competition instruction to the jury was expressly predicated on trade secret misuse, while the tortious interference claim concerned the issue of wrongful and unjustified interference with Conseco's reasonable expectation of economic advantage or benefit. The company, after 20 years in business, had grown tremendously--Conseco's total managed financial assets expanded from $8.2 billion in 1988 to $87.2 billion a decade later. Corp., 136 F.3d 276, 286 (2d Cir. Unsubscribe at any time. They might not be able to make things happen for you, but could give you some insight on how the county handles these matters. HOwever, DiTech said that they only acquired ACTIVE accoutns from Conseco and since it was closed prior to DiTech acquiring them, that they can't do anything about it. Wilton Re's U.S. operating company, Wilton Reassurance Company, has acquired 100% of the common stock of CLIC, a wholly owned subsidiary of CNO consisting of traditional and interest sensitive life insurance policies and deferred annuities in runoff. Indeed, as the insurance industry weathered record insolvencies, Conseco expanded its headquarters and opened an entirely new hub, the Conseco Annuity Center, in Dallas. As stated so eloquently-and simply-by Judge Posner of our sister circuit, "punitive damages should be proportional to the wrongfulness of the defendant's actions." In 1987, it added Western National Life Insurance to its portfolio at a cost of $262 million. A potential obstacle to approval emerged this week when the Securities and Exchange Commission filed an objection to Conseco's disclosure statement and reorganization plan. North American competes for individuals in the same market. Because we have found adequate evidence of the existence of a trade secret, we need not address North American's argument. The purpose of requiring the moving party to articulate the ground on which the Rule 50 judgment is sought "is to give the other party an opportunity to cure the defects in proof that might otherwise preclude him from taking the case to the jury." Conseco . If you still seem to be getting nowhere though, perhaps a call to your local state's Attorney General might help unless you have a lawyer on retainer that could help. North American moved for summary judgment, and the district court granted North American's motion as to misappropriation of customer lists and certain financial information. The company was intended to serve as the primary vehicle for new life insurance acquisitions. Answer some questions about your specific lien and let us help you craft a letter to your creditor to resolve the issue. Take out more than a certain amount, however, and the bank must report the withdrawal to the Internal Revenue Service, which might come around to inquire about why you need all that cash. Copyright (c) 2022 Company-Histories.com. As stated in the company's 1993 annual report, 'Our operating strategy is to consolidate and streamline the administrative functions of the acquired companies, to improve their investment yield through active asset management and to eliminate unprofitable products and distribution channels.'. CCP was then merged into Conseco, and Beneficial Standard Life Insurance and Great American Reserve Insurance, both subsidiaries of CCP, became subsidiaries of Conseco. Proceeds from the sales will help satisfy creditors owed $6.5 billion in parent company debt. We see them around but we don't know what goes on behind the scenes. Who started Conseco insurance? Conseco, in its "First Amended Complaint," added two additional counts-participation in breach of fiduciary duty, and a separate count for injunctive relief. In 1992, just ten years after starting his business, Hilbert was one of the highest paid executives in the United States. Kattleman testified that he was uncertain as to exactly how the customer loan files came to be located in his office at North American. Podner did not specify the exact number of loan applications copied. Conseco appealed the district court's denial of injunctive relief as to its "raiding" claim. All I can say is, I'm buying more.' The companies were Consolidated Marketing Group, Inter-State Service, Inc., and TLC National Marketing Company, which sold products door-to-door. Another of North American's witnesses, Perry Schatz, testified only five percent of Conseco's leads result in a funded loan. How many deaths are caused by flu each year. Lyn-Flex West, Inc. v. Dieckhaus, 24 S.W.3d 693, 697-698 (Mo.App.1999). Copyright 2023 Consumers Unified LLC. During the same period, the value of Conseco's assets ballooned from $11.8 billion to $16.6 billion--a gain of about 30 percent. In other words, the movant cannot use a Rule 50(b) motion "as a vehicle to introduce a legal theory not distinctly articulated in its close-of-evidence motion for a directed verdict." Conseco produced evidence that would allow a reasonable finder of fact to conclude that there was at least a threat of misappropriation of the trade secrets contained in these fourteen files. Some analysts believed that it was just a matter of time before Conseco would fall prey to the asset devaluation that had plagued other fast-growing insurers of the 1980s. US Bank may even accept the Final HUD-1 from 2003 as proof it was paid off. In response, Conseco contends that North American failed to comply with the requirements of Fed. Fair Isaac does not provide "credit repair" services or advice or assistance regarding "rebuilding" or "improving" your credit record, credit history or credit rating. You basically need to say the following to US Bank "You did our refinance back in 2003 and it was based on the existing trust deed with Greentree being paid in full and satisfied at closing, which it was paid in full and satisfied, but the company failed to record a reconveyance and that is why their trust deed still appears on our title. Accordingly, we find no error in the submission, This figure is based on the net worth of North American Mortgage, a division of Dime Savings Bank of New York. Both motions were denied by the district court, and the case was submitted to the jury on Conseco's claims of unfair competition and tortious interference. Ins. Green Tree was Conseco's first acquisition not related to insurance, and it was also the largest of Conseco's acquisitions--Conseco reportedly paid about $6 billion in stock for Green Tree. In addition to its insurance and financial management divisions, which accounted for more than 85 percent of Conseco's operations in 1993, the company was broadening its scope to include some nontraditional ventures.
Chuck Lorre Productions,
Saladin Armoured Car Northern Ireland,
Wipeout Course Open To Public California,
Articles W